Should you rent or buy?
Compare the monthly cost of buying a home against renting — then see the total cost of each over the years you plan to stay, including equity you build.
Verified November 2026
Quick answer: rent or buy a $450,000 home?
Buying wins by $43,117 over 7 years, on the calculator's own math. A $450,000 home with $90,000 down leaves a $360,000 loan at 7.28% over 30 years. Principal and interest are $2,463.16 a month, plus $412.50 tax, $131.25 insurance and $375 maintenance: $3,381.91 all in. Rent for a comparable place is $2,200 a month. Over 7 years you pay $383,080 to own and $202,289 to rent, but you walk away with $223,908 of equity, so owning nets out at $159,172. Put your own price, rent and rate in the calculator below to see yours.
How it is worked out: monthly rate = 7.28% / 12 = 0.6067%. Payment = $360,000 × 0.0060667 × 8.8234 / 7.8234 = $2,463.16. After 7 years the home is worth $553,443 at 3% appreciation a year, the loan balance is $329,535, and equity is $223,908. In those 7 years $176,440 of your payments is interest and only $30,465 reduces the balance.
Why renting can still win: the money you do not put down
Renting is cheaper month to month. The buyer pays $262,615 over 7 years that never comes back: $176,440 interest, $77,175 tax, insurance and maintenance, $9,000 closing costs. The renter pays $202,289 in rent. Buying only wins because of the equity.
Now count what the page leaves out. If the renter invests the $90,000 down payment plus $9,000 closing costs, and the monthly difference between owning and renting, at 7% a year, the portfolio reaches $268,662 after 7 years. If the buyer sells and pays 6% selling costs, the buyer nets $190,702. The renter is ahead by $77,960. The answer flips when you count selling costs and what the down payment could have earned. If you would not actually invest the difference every month, use the first answer, not this one.
How long you stay changes the answer
| Years you stay | Net cost of buying | Total rent paid | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | $120,110 | $140,161 | Buying wins by $20,051 |
| 7 | $159,172 | $202,289 | Buying wins by $43,117 |
| 10 | $210,997 | $302,646 | Buying wins by $91,650 |
Longer stays favor buying, because the $99,000 up front (down payment plus closing) spreads over more years and equity compounds. Short stays favor renting, because closing costs and selling costs eat the equity before it builds.
Check your price-to-rent ratio first
Price divided by annual rent. Here it is $450,000 / $26,400 = 17.0. Under about 15 usually favors buying, over about 20 usually favors renting, and 17 sits between the two, which is why the two frames above disagree. A $450,000 home at $3,000 a month rent is a ratio of 12.5 and a much clearer buy. The same home at $1,800 a month rent is a ratio of 20.8 and a much clearer rent.
Fixed-rate loan at 7.28%, the Freddie Mac weekly average for the week ending November 19, 2026, which is also the calculator's default rate. Tax 1.1%, insurance 0.35% and maintenance 1% of the home price per year, rent growing 3% a year, home value growing 3% a year. The 7% investment return and 6% selling cost in the second section are assumptions, not market promises. This does not include HOA dues or tax deductions, and the tool charges tax, insurance and maintenance on today's price, not the appreciated value.
Method: buying cost = down payment + 2% closing costs + monthly costs (P&I, tax, insurance, maintenance) over your horizon, minus home equity at the end (appreciated value minus remaining loan). Renting cost = rent growing yearly. Simplified estimate — it excludes tax deductions, HOA dues, selling costs, and investment returns on the down payment. Educational only, not financial advice.